180 Seconds
A long while back, John Scalzi wrote a post in which he invited readers to look at their iTunes libraries and list out the songs that came in at exactly three minutes - the idea being to take a tongue in cheek at the oft-repeated claim that three minutes is the perfect length for a pop song. Now at the time, I didn't have my music library all digitized, but now I do and I was curious to see which pop songs in my collection were at that ideal length.
Is That All? - U2
Not a classic pop song, really, more of a dirge-y type of thing.
I've Got My Love to Keep Me Warm - Ella Fitzgerald
The very definition of perfection, methinks.
Spirits in the Material World - The Police
Pretty good, tight pop song.
Gimme' Some Loving - The Loving Spoonful
Another pretty perfect pop song. This might work!
Sloop John B - Beach Boys
Another tough one to argue.
Rumbleseat - John Mellencamp
This is awesome? Another great, punchy, burst of a song.
The Great Unknown - Elvis Costello
Still good.
Sleigh Ride - Johnny Mathis
Yep.
Let's Begin - Ella Fitzgerald
Yep.
Dance Naked - John Mellencamp
Yep.
Halloween (Live) - Dave Matthews Band
Not perfect, no.
So Sad About Us - The Who
A great Who pop song.
Watch Your Step - Elvis Costello
Pinball Wizard - The Who
Come on!
John Wesley Harding - Bob Dylan
Dream - Ella Fitzgerald
This Year's Kiss - Nina Simone
Ring Then Bells - Bob Dylan
O Tannenbaum - Nat King Cole
Can't Help Falling In Love
Sheer perfection.
St. Louis Blues - Louis Armstrong
Orange Blossom Special - Johnny Cash
That was kind of a fun experiment.
3 comments:
The first song I KNEW to be three minutes was Classical Gas by Mason Williams, used on a montage of the history of the world on the Smothers Brothers Show.
Oh, and memory serves, the Canadian version of the Beatles song Penny Lane single, with the piccolo trumpet outro from the American album Rarities.
Post a Comment