Monday, November 05, 2007

Dead Mother

I don't know why, but I can't stop thinking about how the reveal of who the mother is and what her story with Ted will be (when they eventually get to it) on How I Met Your Mother. My newest thought, as the title hints at, is - what if the mother is dead? Granted, this pretty down and macabre twist might not play well in a sitcom, but there is a certain logic to it. After all, Future Ted is telling his kids this story in very drawn-out fashion - rather than give them the short version he's detailed 50 (so far) short stories, without even (we assume) introducing the mother yet. Why would someone do this? If the mother died when the kids were young, it would make sense to go into this long and detailed history. Especially if the kids were raised by Aunt Robin - if Robin and Ted do end up together, not as a couple, but as a widower and close friend raising his kids. This would explain the sheer tonnage of material about Aunt Robin he's giving the kids - for, if Aunt Robin was just a friend, would the kids really need this much detail?

In an episode from a few weeks back, we got a quick tag of a high Future Ted asking where his wife was. We were to assume that it was a random, pot-fueled non-sequiter designed to remind us, the audience, that there is a mother. However, given the show's abundant love of letting context reveal hidden meanings, what if the real point was that the mother is gone, and this was a kind of sad moment for Ted, as in his stoned state he asked after his dead wife?

OK. Maybe not.

Until Whenever

11 comments:

bill said...

Kinda depressing and makes complete sense.

Tosy And Cosh said...

The depressing thing has me highly doubtful that I'll be proven right, but it does fit, no?

R.A. Porter said...

Tosy, saw this yesterday and wanted to mull it over for a bit. I think you might be on to something. It would certainly be interesting and bittersweet if the mother will have passed away by the time Ted's telling the kids the story.

My guess is Bays and Thomas aren't going to go for that payoff, but I do like it.

bill said...

I'd like to request a new post so "Dead mother" isn't the first thing I see.

thank you.

Tosy And Cosh said...

Ask and you shall receive. ;)

bill said...

thanks!

Anonymous said...

found this blog via twitter. would love to see this theory revised, especially after tonights episode!!

Roger Owen Green said...

The premise of the show has kept me away from it. I don't think I've ever seen a full episode.

J. van Eijndhoven said...

Dude. Wow. This is nuts. And frankly, I really didn't like the finale. But you were right. Damn...

Kaylee Farnes said...

I'm incredibly amazed! You hit it spot on! I hated the finale but I'm super impressed you caught it.

whenthecowscomedancinghome.blogspot.com

Anonymous said...

Wow, you caught it so soon!!!